In New York in 2011, a fifteen-year-old girl is found crucified in a suburban church. Around the same time, investigative journalist Miren Triggs receives a Polaroid of a bound and gagged girl, accompanied by the name Gina Pebbles and the year 2002. The image gives her a second mystery to pursue.

Two trails to follow

Miren joins Jim Schmoer, her former journalism teacher, to investigate the photograph while following the case of the crucified teenager. Their inquiries take them into a secretive religious institution, where they must work out what happened to Gina, who sent the Polaroid and whether the two cases are connected.