The shortage behind dissection

In the early nineteenth century, surgeons’ training required dissection, but the legal supply of bodies was limited. The 1752 law allowed the bodies of people executed for murder to be used; that provision could not meet the demand from anatomy schools. The gap encouraged body-snatching: people exhumed the recently buried and sold their bodies to anatomists. This historical context offers one way to approach Frankenstein, without assuming that the novel’s fictional circumstances directly reproduce these events.

From grave-robbing to murder

The clandestine trade in bodies should be distinguished from murders committed to obtain them. The Royal College of Surgeons’ archival account separates grave-robbing from cases such as Burke and Hare, who killed people in Edinburgh and sold their bodies. The public outrage these crimes provoked intensified debate over the supply of cadavers and the ethics of dissection.

Who decided the fate of the bodies?

Who could decide that a body would be used for anatomical teaching? Before 1832, the law permitted the dissection of people executed for murder; in Glasgow, the university received only 23 bodies during the eighty years from 1752 to 1832. The Anatomy Act of 1832 changed the legal framework, allowing surgeons and students to dissect bodies left unclaimed after death, including those of people who died in workhouses, prisons, and hospitals. The sources document a change in which bodies could legally enter medical teaching, but they do not, by themselves, answer whether people who died in those institutions had consented. This history raises a question for reading Frankenstein: how does judgment about the use of bodies change when the person deciding their fate—and the authority behind that decision—changes? This is a thematic comparison, not evidence that these historical events gave rise to the novel or that Mary Shelley referred to them.